Gone Without A Trace: Family reflects on three who disappeared in Turley one year ago

TURLEY, Okla. — The family of two men and one woman who disappeared at a ranch in the north Tulsa community of Turley one year ago are sharing their thoughts, feelings, and even what they personally witnessed with FOX23 News in the hopes that someone will come forward with new information to close the case.

In mid-October 2021, Jack Grimes and his friends and business partner Dwayne Selby were planning to attend a show horse convention in Fort Worth, Texas, but they never made it. After days of unanswered phone calls, their family, including Dwayne’s mother Glenda “Cookie” Parton would begin looking for the men while the law enforcement search got underway.

However, Cookie herself would also disappear.

“Anything random. Nothing random makes any sense,” Carol Selby, Cookie’s daughter-in-law said. “No one would be out to hurt her. She had no enemies.”

FOX23 spoke with Carol and Jack’s sister Nancy Clayton. Jack’s remains were found one miles west of his Turley home, but Cookie and Dwayne disappeared without a trace.

“Every time I think about it, there’s things I can’t quite get my head around,” Nancy said. “It’s probably why police are having such a hard time figuring things out too.”

Tonight on FOX23 News at 9, hear more from Carol and Nancy and get an update from the Tulsa County Sheriff’s Office about why they say this isn’t a cold case.